Craving something cold, creamy, and absolutely irresistible? York County is home to some incredible ice cream shops that serve up everything from fresh fruit flavors to indulgent custards and cupcake-infused creations. Each stop on this list offers its own unique twist on this timeless treat, so get ready to explore the best spots for a scoop, a swirl, or a sundae.
Springs Farm Market: Farm-Fresh Flavor in Every Scoop
A visit to Springs Farm Market is a chance to enjoy some of the best homemade ice cream in town. Their strawberry ice cream is made with berries grown right on-site, giving it a flavor that’s as fresh as it gets.
For something a little different, their Cherry Lemon Sundrop Slushie is a local favorite, offering the perfect balance of tart and sweet. If you’re grabbing a quick cone or settling in for a refreshing frozen treat, this stop is a must for fruit lovers.
Abbott’s Frozen Custard: Rich, Creamy, and Decadent
Abbott’s Frozen Custard is all about smooth, velvety texture and rich flavors. Their frozen custard is made fresh daily using a time-honored family recipe that has been delighting customers for generations.
The menu features everything from classic cones to fully loaded sundaes, but the standout is their signature dessert, The Turtle. This masterpiece combines layers of creamy custard, crunchy peanuts, and rich fudge, all coated in dark chocolate. It’s an experience with every bite.
Smallcakes Cupcakery and Creamery: A Sweet Fusion of Cupcakes and Ice Cream
At Smallcakes Cupcakery and Creamery, the magic happens when gourmet cupcakes and homemade ice cream come together. Their unique flavors are inspired by their famous cupcakes, blending the best of both worlds into one unforgettable dessert.
Each day brings up to 14 freshly baked cupcake flavors, and their ice cream is crafted to match. A scoop of cupcake-infused ice cream next to a freshly frosted cupcake is the kind of pairing that makes any day a little brighter.
Bruster’s Real Ice Cream: Handcrafted Treats in a Waffle Cone
Bruster’s Real Ice Cream is known for its fresh, homemade flavors made on-site every single day. With over 140 recipes in rotation, there’s always something new to try, from classic vanilla and chocolate to bold, fruity creations.
Their signature waffle cones and bowls take things to the next level, adding a warm, crispy contrast to the cold, creamy goodness inside. If it’s a rich fudge swirl or a tangy raspberry sundae, Bruster’s delivers pure ice cream happiness in every scoop.
Scoop n’ Swirl: Homemade Ice Cream with Heart
Scoop n’ Swirl specializes in small-batch, handcrafted ice cream that’s made with care and served with a smile. Each flavor is created using fresh ingredients, ensuring a rich and creamy texture that keeps customers coming back.
The shop’s welcoming atmosphere makes every visit feel like a special occasion. Under new ownership, but still dedicated to quality, it continues to be a go-to spot for those who appreciate the simple joy of great ice cream.
